1. Mary Jane Kelly said she had a brother named Henry in the Scots Guard. Henry Sinclair, grandfather of the builder of Rosslyn Chapel, came from a family of Scots Guard. Sinclair promoted the association of Rosslyn with many Arthurian legends and Arthur Sullivan, named Arthur of course, wrote incidental music for a King Arthur opera.

You want to give me 3 similarities for a random example? Are you sure? I happen to actually believe in the Rule of Three, as expressed by Goldfinger. One is happenstance, Two is coinicidence and Three is enemy action!

I tend to think these types of Grail legend/stories/hoaxes are a vestige of the 60s. I have 2 examples starting in the 70s. A third, if you could come up with one, would at least prove to me it’s more than mere coincidence.

Fou Cault - 02 May 2008 09:47 PM

1. Mary Jane Kelly said she had a brother named Henry in the Scots Guard. Henry Sinclair, grandfather of the builder of Rosslyn Chapel, came from a family of Scots Guard. Sinclair promoted the association of Rosslyn with many Arthurian legends and Arthur Sullivan, named Arthur of course, wrote incidental music for a King Arthur opera.

You want to give me 3 similarities for a random example? Are you sure? I happen to actually believe in the Rule of Three, as expressed by Goldfinger. One is happenstance, Two is coinicidence and Three is enemy action!

I tend to think these types of Grail legend/stories/hoaxes are a vestige of the 60s. I have 2 examples starting in the 70s. A third, if you could come up with one, would at least prove to me it’s more than mere coincidence.

I forget you are new here.  I’m saying give a couple of random events, say the May 2005 eruption of Mt. St. Helens and the death of Princess Diana.  Nothing to do with each other.  I’m willing to bet that David could come up with a plausible connection to show you how many people are taken in by the kind of logic you describe in the first post of the thread.  If you picked out two similar events (or even three) there wouldn’t be much of a challenge.  I picked on David and Acci because I’ve seen the two genius’ do it with quite some flair in the past.

WaveOfMutilation has just asked for similarities between the Norman conquest and the formation of the Milk Marketing Board.
Well, David? Acci?

Fou Cault - 02 May 2008 09:47 PM

I have 2 ["holy grail/bloodline"] examples starting in the 70s. A third, if you could come up with one, would at least prove to me it’s more than mere coincidence.

How could I forget? Joseph Sickert who recounted the Royal Conspiracy for the BBC in 1973 was said to be the son of the artist Walter and Elizabeth Crook, the secret daughter of Prince Eddy and Alice Crook. I believe some of that to be fact-based. Who’s to say Prince Eddy didn’t have a kid? I don’t think this one had anything to do with the Ripper case though.
Mary’s alleged child has to be a different story if he is real. I know the newspapers reported Mary had a child and never retracted it. An error? Leading to a hoax? How can you prove it’s all a mistake or a hoax if it’s unsolved?

Boo - 03 May 2008 03:58 AM

WaveOfMutilation has just asked for similarities between the Norman conquest and the formation of the Milk Marketing Board.
Well, David? Acci?

Any particular Milk Marketing Board?

Let’s see. . .well, the Pennsylvania MMB website has a picture of a Holstein cow on it.  The state of Holstein was, of course, the territory of the Duke of Holstein-Gottorp, who later became czar Peter III of Russia.  As everyone knows, Peter III was overthrown by his wife, Catherine (the Great), who then set out on a program to modernise Russia. . .in large part by taking the example of France.  This involved the settlement of lots of people from France in Russia.  And of course, the Norman Conquest involved a lot of people from what is now France settling in Britain.

Furthermore, looking around at the history of the formation of the PMMB, I see lots of words written in Modern English.  The last of the major influences on the English language was, of course, the melding of the Anglo-Saxon language with the Norman langauge after the Norman Conquest.

And finally, remember that Harold Godwinson’s sons raided the Norman invaders in Devon around 1068.  And of course Devon cattle are related to the same original wild cattle that were domesticated long ago and led to the eventual rise of the commercial milk industry. . .and thus to the formation of milk marketing boards.

That’s the best I can do right now, as I’m a bit rushed for time. 

*applauds*

Normans and Milk?

Howard Brown of jtrforums and Roslyn Hoax fame is a direct descendant of William the Conqueror. AND he likes to eat Philly cheesesteaks, cheese being a dairy product!

Howard Brown [...] is a direct descendant of William the Conqueror

*pfeeep!* Unsupported assertion, that’s a five yard penalty and loss of down!

Not at all bad for a rushed job, Acci.

Sorry, Fou, those are not the events I listed…

I am so missing the connections here.

Fou Cault - 02 May 2008 09:47 PM

1. Mary Jane Kelly said she had a brother named Henry in the Scots Guard. Henry Sinclair, grandfather of the builder of Rosslyn Chapel, came from a family of Scots Guard. Sinclair promoted the association of Rosslyn with many Arthurian legends and Arthur Sullivan, named Arthur of course, wrote incidental music for a King Arthur opera.

You want to give me 3 similarities for a random example? Are you sure? I happen to actually believe in the Rule of Three, as expressed by Goldfinger. One is happenstance, Two is coinicidence and Three is enemy action!

I tend to think these types of Grail legend/stories/hoaxes are a vestige of the 60s. I have 2 examples starting in the 70s. A third, if you could come up with one, would at least prove to me it’s more than mere coincidence.

Henry Sinclair, a member of the Royal Scots Guards, a regiment founded in 1642, built Rosslyn Chapel?

Which was built in the 15th century?